| 2025 | Kyron Drones, Kelvin Gilliam, Benji Gosnell, John Love |
| 2024 | Sam Brumfield, Kyron Drones, Da'Quan Felton, Kaden Moore, Peter Moore, Cole Nelson, Dorian Strong |
| 2023 | Josh Fuga, Nick Gallo, Kaden Moore, Peter Moore, Nasir Peoples, Norell Pollard, Grant Wells |
| 2022 | Chamarri Conner, Silas Dzansi, Dax Hollifield, Peter Moore, Norell Pollard, Kaleb Smith, Grant Wells |
| 2021 | Chamarri Conner, Brock Hoffman, Dax Hollifield, James Mitchell, Tyrell Smith |
| 2020 | Rayshard Ashby, Divine Deablo, Jarrod Hewitt, Tyrell Smith |
| 2019 | Divine Deablo, Reggie Floyd, Jarrod Hewitt, Dalton Keene, Tyrell Smith |
| 2018 | Kyle Chung, Reggie Floyd, Josh Jackson, Ricky Walker |
| 2017 | Eric Gallo, Andrew Motuapuaka, Anthony Shegog, Greg Stroman |
| 2016 | Woody Baron, Chuck Clark, Jonathan McLaughlin, Sam Rogers |
| 2015 | Michael Brewer, JC Coleman, Luther Maddy, Ryan Malleck |
| 2014 | Detrick Bonner, Willie Byrn, Kyshoen Jarrett, Chase Williams |
| 2013 | Kyle Fuller, Andrew Miller, Logan Thomas, Jack Tyler |
| 2012 | Nick Becton, Vinston Painter, Joey Phillips, Bruce Taylor |
| 2011 | Danny Coale, Blake DeChristopher, Chris Drager, Eddie Whitley |
| 2010 | John Graves, Davon Morgan, Andre Smith, Tyrod Taylor |
| 2009 | Nekos Brown, Kam Chancellor, Cody Grimm, Ed Wang |
| 2008 | Macho Harris, Orion Martin, Ryan Shuman, Brett Warren |
| 2007 | Xavier Adibi, Duane Brown, Chris Ellis, Carlton Weatherford |
| 2006 | Noland Burchette, Danny McGrath, Brandon Pace, Aaron Rouse |
| 2005 | Justin Hamilton, Jeff King, Jonathan Lewis, Will Montgomery, Darryl Tapp, Jimmmy Wiliams |
| 2004 | Mikal Baaqee, Jim Davis, Vincent Fuller, Eric Green, Jared Mazzetta, Bryan Randall |
| 2003 | Nathaniel Adibi, Michael Crawford, Doug Easlick, Jake Grove |
| 2002 | Anthony Davis, Willie Pile, Lee Suggs, Shawn Witten |
| 2001 | Chad Beasley, André Davis, Jarrett Ferguson, Ben Taylor |
| 2000 | Cory Bird, Andre Kendrick, Matt Lehr, Dave Meyer, Phillip Summers |
| 1999 | John Engelberger, Michael Hawkes, Anthony Midget, Corey Moore, Keith Short |
| 1998 | Keion Carpenter, Al Clark, Pierson Prioleau, Derek Smith, Dwight Vick |
| 1997 | Gennaro DiNapoli, Kerwin Hairston, Ken Oxendine, Marcus Parker, Steve Tate, Todd Washington |
| 1996 | Cornell Brown, Billy Conaty, Jim Druckenmiller, Waverly Jackson, Myron Newsome, Brandon Semones |
| 1995 | Mike Bianchin, Hank Coleman, George DelRicco, Jermaine Holmes, J.C. Price |
| 1994 | Ken Brown, Maurice DeShazo, Antonio Freeman, Damien McMahon, Ranall White |
| 1993 | Bernard Basham, John Burke, Tyronne Drakeford, Jim Pyne, Joe Swarm |
| 1992 | Melendez Byrd, Rusty Pendleton, Mark Poindexter, Jerome Preston |
| 1991 | William Boatwright, Phil Bryant, Eugene Chung, Wooster Pack |
| 1990 | Al Chamblee, Nick Cullen, Archie Hopkins, Jimmy Whitten |
| 1989 | Randy Cockrella, Scott Hill, Bobby Martin, Brian McCall |
| 1988 | Randy Cockrell, Todd Grantham, Scott Hill, Bobby Martin, Horacio Moronta |
| 1987 | Erik Chapman, Steve Johnson, Kevin Keeffe, Carter Wiley |
| 1986 | Curtis Taliaferro, Maurice Williams |
| 1985 | Rainer Coleman, Kent Thomas |
| 1984 | Joe Jones, Ashley Lee, Bruce Smith |
| 1983 | Mike Johnson, Tony Paige |
| 1982 | Rick Miley, Padro Phillips, Mark Udinski |
| 1981 | Robert Brown, Steve Casey |
| 1980 | Paul Davis, Sidney Snell, Lewis Stuart |
| 1979 | Mike Faulkner, Mickey Fitzgerald, Danny Hill, Kenny Lewis |
| 1978 | Chip Keatley, Dennis Scott |
| 1977 | Roscoe Coles, Bill Houseright, Rick Razzano, George Roberts |
| 1976 | Paul Adams, Mitcheal Barnes, Tom Beasley |
| 1975 | Phil Rogers, Doug Thacke |
| 1974 | Charlie Martin, Randy Ve |
| 1973 | Game Captains |
| 1972 | Game Captains |
| 1971 | Game Captains |
| 1970 | Jim Pigninelli, Perry Tiberio |
| 1969 | Steve Bocko, Pete Dawyot, Jerry Green |
| 1968 | Frank Beamer, Ron Davidson, Waddey Harvey |
| 1967 | Bob Griffith, Frank Loria |
| 1966 | Dave Farmer, Tommy Groom, Sands Woody |
| 1965 | Billy Edwards, Bobby Owens, Mike Saunders |
| 1964 | Vic Kreiter, Darrell Page, Bob Schweickert |
| 1963 | Gene Breen, Newt Green |
| 1962 | Davo Gillespie, Aster Sizemore |
| 1961 | Joe Moss, Terry Strock |
| 1960 | Allen Whittier |
| 1959 | Carroll Dale |
| 1958 | Jim Burke |
| 1957 | Corbin Bailey |
| 1956 | Don Divors |
| 1955 | Dickie Beard, Jack Prater |
| 1954 | Billy Kerfoot, Howie Wright |
| 1950 | Ron Casto |
| 1949 | Bruce Fisher, Jack Ittner |
| 1948 | Tom Burns, Oren Hopkins |
| 1947 | Bill Barbour, Bobby Smith |
| 1946 | Floyd Bowles, Elmer Wilson |
| 1942 | W. James, S.D. Tilson |
| 1941 | William M. Tate |
| 1940 | John Henderson, William Zydiak |
| 1939 | Jim Coleman, Dave Pitts |
| 1938 | Frank Pierce |
| 1937 | C.L. Shockey |
| 1936 | Dave Jones |
| 1935 | Louis Fittro |
| 1934 | George Smith |
| 1933 | Bill Porterfield |
| 1932 | W. Grinus, Jr. |
| 1931 | C.E. Brown |
| 1930 | H.V. Hooper |
| 1929 | L.B. Nutter |
| 1928 | A.E. Balley |
| 1927 | V.E. Miles |
| 1926 | J.H. Moran |
| 1925 | J.H. Moran |
| 1924 | S.O. Graham |
| 1923 | H.M. Sutton |
| 1922 | H.J. Hardwick |
| 1921 | S.D. Tilson |
| 1920 | H.B. Redd |
| 1919 | J.T. Hardwick |
| 1918 | H. Crisp, D. Roden |
| 1917 | HT. Parrish |
| 1916 | J.S. Caffee |
| 1915 | V.F. Dixon |
| 1914 | M.F. Peak, Jr. |
| 1913 | L.A. Pick |
| 1912 | W.H. Burruss |
| 1911 | A.G. Gibbs |
| 1910 | V.B. Hodgson |
| 1909 | E.R. Hodgson |
| 1908 | Joe Luttrell |
| 1907 | C.E. Diffendal |
| 1906 | J.A. Nutter |
| 1905 | T.W. Lewis |
| 1904 | G.C. Willson |
| 1903 | C.P. Miles |
| 1902 | C.H. Carpenter |
| 1901 | C.J.B. DeCamp |
| 1900 | J.B. Hufford |
| 1899 | W.F. Cox |
| 1898 | C.M. Wood |
| 1897 | H.A. Johnson |
| 1896 | J.L. Ingles |
| 1895 | J.L. Ingles |
| 1894 | T.D. Martin |
| 1893 | S.V. Lovenstein |
| 1892 | W.E. Anderson |