| 1987 (3) | Jon Jeffries | 92-yd. kickoff return | Clemson |
| Don Stokes | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Syracuse |
| Randy Cockrell | 90-yd. interception return | Navy |
| 1988 (4) | Don Stokes | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Southern Miss |
| Jock Jones | recovered blocked punt in end zone | West Virginia |
| Roger Brown | 55-yd. interception return | South Carolina |
| Leslie Bailey | 19-yd. interception return | South Carolina |
| 1989 (3) | Marcus Mickel | 90-yd. kickoff return | Clemson |
| Jock Jones | 55-yd. interception return | Tulane |
| Roger Brown | 55-yd. interception return | NC State |
| 1990 (0) | none |
| 1991 (3) | P.J. Preston | recovered fumble in end zone | Oklahoma |
| Ken Landrum | 18-yd. blocked punt return | Cincinnati |
| Kirk Alexander | 95-yd. interception return | Cincinnati |
| 1992 (3) | Tyronne Drakeford | 40-yd. interception return | East Carolina |
| Tony Kennedy | 91-yd. kickoff return | Louisville |
| Ken Brown | 18-yd. interception return | Rutgers |
| 1993 (5) | William Ferrell | 7-yd. blocked punt return | Rutgers |
| DeWayne Knight | 23-yd. fumble return | Syracuse |
| Jeff Holland | 8-yd. fumble return | Virginia |
| Lawrence Lewis | 20-yd. fumble return | Indiana |
| Antonio Banks | 80-yd. blocked field goal return | Indiana |
| 1994 (4) | Torrian Gray | 66-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| Stacy Henley | 25-yd. blocked punt return | Temple |
| LawrenceLewis | 60-yd. fumble return | East Carolina |
| AntonioFreeman | 80-yd. punt return | Pitt |
| 1995 (9) | Jermaine Holmes | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Akron |
| Hank Coleman | 51-yd. fumble return | Rutgers |
| Myron Newsome | 71-yd. interception return | Rutgers |
| Larry Green | 37-yd. interception return | West Virginia |
| Jim Baron | 46-yd. fumble return | Temple |
| J.C. Price | 19-yd. interception return | Temple |
| Antonio Banks | 65-yd. interception return | Virginia |
| Bryan Still | 60-yd. punt return | Texas |
| Jim Baron | 20-yd. fumble return | Texas |
| 1996 (2) | Cornelius White | 60-yd. blocked punt return | Syracuse |
| KeionCarpenter | 100-yd. interception return | Miami |
| 1997 (4) | Carl Bradley | recovered fumble in end zone | Rutgers |
| PiersonPrioleau | 43-yd. fumble return | Rutgers |
| Lorenzo Ferguson | 84-yd. interception return | Arkansas State |
| Anthony Midget | 22-yd. fumble return | Pitt |
| 1998 (9) | Keion Carpenter | 16-yd. interception return | Pitt |
| Pierson Prioleau | 85-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| Marcus Gildersleeve | recovered blocked punt in end zone | UAB |
| Ricky Hall | 17-yd. blocked punt return | West Virginia |
| Ricky Hall | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Syracuse |
| Loren Johnson | 78-yd. fumble return | Syracuse |
| Ike Charlton | 26-yd. interception return | Rutgers |
| Jamel Smith | 98-yd. interception return | Rutgers |
| Anthony Midget | 27-yd. interception return | Alabama |
| 1999 (8) | Ike Charlton | 34-yd. interception return | Clemson |
| Corey Moore | 32-yd. fumble return | Clemson |
| Cory Bird | 26-yd. fumble return | Syracuse |
| Phillip Summers | 43-yd. interception return | Syracuse |
| Tee Butler | recovered fumble by punter in end zone | Syracuse |
| Ricky Hall | 64-yd. punt return | Miami |
| Ike Charlton | 51-yd. fumble return | Miami |
| Larry Austin | 31-yd. interception return | Temple |
| 2000 (6) | Willie Pile | 11-yd. interception return | Akron |
| Cory Bird | 9-yd. blocked punt return | East Carolina |
| André Davis | 87-yd. punt return | East Carolina |
| André Davis | 71-yd. punt return | Boston College |
| André Davis | 76-yd. punt return | WVU |
| Nathaniel Adibi | 36-yd. fumble return | UCF |
| 2001 (7) | Channing Reed | 8-yd. fumble return | Rutgers |
| Kevin McCadam | 69-yd. interception return | UCF |
| André Davis | 55-yd. punt return | UCF |
| Jim Davis | 27-yd. interception return | West Virginia |
| Kevin McCadam | 9-yd. fumble return | Boston College |
| Ronyell Whitaker | 71-yd. blocked field goal return | Pitt |
| Brandon Manning | 22-yd. blocked punt return | Miami |
| 2002 (7) | DeAngelo Hall | 69-yd. punt return | Arkansas State |
| DeAngelo Hall | 49-yd. interception return | Arkansas State |
| Jason Lallis | 59-yd. fumble return | Arkansas State |
| Alex Markogiannakis | 25-yd. fumble return | Western Michigan |
| DeAngelo Hall | 51-yd. punt return | Rutgers |
| Darryl Tapp | 11-yd. blocked punt return | Virginia |
| Willie Pile | 96-yd. interception return | Miami |
| 2003 (11) | Jason Lallis | 45-yd. interception return | UCF |
| Eric Green | 84-yd. interception return | UConn |
| Mike Imoh | 91-yd. kickoff return | UConn |
| Chris Clifton | 16-yd. blocked punt return | UConn |
| Jimmy Williams | 55-yd. interception return | Rutgers |
| DeAngelo Hall | 58-yd. punt return | Syracuse |
| DeAngelo Hall | 60-yd. punt return | Syracuse |
| Vincent Fuller | 50-yd. fumble return | West Virginia |
| DeAngelo Hall | 28-yd. fumble return | Miami |
| Eric Green | 51-yd. interception return | Miami |
| DeAngelo Hall | 52-yd. punt return | Cal |
| 2004 (6) | Jason Lallis | 28-yd. fumble return | Western Michigan |
| Brandon Flowers | 38-yd. interception return | Western Michigan |
| Vincent Fuller | 74-yd. blocked field goal return | West Virginia |
| Blake Warren | 46-yd. interception return | Florida A&M |
| Roland Minor | 64-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| Jimmy Williams | 34-yd. interception return | Maryland |
| 2005 (7) | Roland Minor | 23-yd. interception return | Duke |
| D.J. Parker | 78-yd. blocked field goal return | Georgia Tech |
| Xavier Adibi | 25-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| Chris Ellis | 29-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| Vince Hall | 15-yd. fumble return | Marshall |
| Vince Hall | 13-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| James Anderson | 39-yd. interception return | Louisville |
| 2006 (5) | Brenden Hill | 69-yd. interception return | North Carolina |
| Eddie Royal | 58-yd. punt return | Duke |
| Victor “Macho” Harris | 72-yd. interception return | Cincinnati |
| Noland Burchette | 15-yd. fumble return | Kent State |
| Xavier Adibi | 35-yd. fumble return | Wake Forest |
| 2007 (9) | Victor “Macho” Harris | 17-yd. interception return | EastCarolina |
| Brandon Flowers | 49-yd. interception return | William & Mary |
| Eddie Royal | 60-yd. punt return | William & Mary |
| D.J. Parker | 32-yd. interception return | Clemson |
| Eddie Royal | 82-yd. punt return | Clemson |
| Victor “Macho” Harris | 100-yd. kickoff return | Clemson |
| Chris Ellis | 5-yd. interception return | Florida State |
| Xavier Adibi | 40-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| Justin Harper | 84-yd. punt return | Kansas |
| 2008 (5) | Stephan Virgil | 30-yd. fumble return | East Carolina |
| Brett Warren | 36-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| Victor “Macho” Harris | 55-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| Victor “Macho” Harris | 23-yd. interception return | Duke |
| Orion Martin | 17-yd. fumble return | Boston College |
| 2009 (4) | Dyrell Roberts | 98-yd. kickoff return | Alabama |
| Jayron Hosley | 64-yd. punt return | Marshall |
| Matt Reidy | 1-yd. blocked punt return | Miami |
| Rashad Carmichael | 22-yd. interception return | Boston College |
| 2010 (5) | Rashad Carmichael | 68-yd. interception return | EastCarolina |
| David Wilson | 92-yd. kickoff return | NC State |
| Jayron Hosley | 80-yd. punt return | Central Michigan |
| David Wilson | 90-yd. kickoff return | Georgia Tech |
| Jeron Gouveia-Winslow | 24-yd. interception return | Florida State |
| 2011 (1) | Kyle Fuller | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Appalachian State |
| 2012 (2) | Kyshoen Jarrett | 94-yd. punt return | Pitt |
| Demitri Knowles | 93-yd. kickoff return | North Carolina |
| 2013 (2) | Detrick Bonner | 37-yd. interception return | Western Carolina |
| Derek Di Nardo | 11-yd. recovered blocked punt | Marshall |
| 2014 (5) | Donovan Riley | 63-yd. interception return | Ohio State |
| Andrew Motuapuaka | 11-yd. fumble return on kickoff | Western Michigan |
| Kendall Fuller | 47-yd. interception return | North Carolina |
| Bucky Hodges | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Virginia |
| Greg Stroman | 12-yd. fumble return | Cincinnati |
| 2015 (5) | Andrew Motuapuaka | 18-yd. interception return | Furman |
| Chuck Clark | 20-yd. fumble return | Purdue |
| Anthony Shegog | 15-yd. recovered blocked punt | Purdue |
| Andrew Motuapuaka | 34-yd. fumble return | Boston College |
| Greg Stroman | 67-yd. punt return | Tulsa |
| 2016 (3) | Greg Stroman | 87-yd. punt return | East Carolina |
| Adonis Alexander | 75-yd. blocked field goal return | Duke |
| Andrew Motuapuaka | 70-yd. fumble return | Virginia |
| 2017 (5) | Greg Stroman | 61-yd. punt return | Delaware |
| Ricky Walker | 12-yd. fumble return | North Carolina |
| Greg Stroman | 91-yd. punt return | North Carolina |
| Reggie Floyd | 69-yd. interception return | North Carolina |
| Greg Stroman | 24-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| 2018 (2) | Eric Kumah | 3-yd. recovered blocked punt | Florida State |
| Jovonn Quillen | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Virginia |
| 2019 (3) | Divine Deablo | 98-yd. fumble return | Notre Dame |
| Caleb Farley | 17-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| Norell Pollard | 7-yd. fumble return | Pitt |
| 2020 (0) | none |
| 2021 (4) | Tayvion Robinson | 60-yd. punt return | Richmond |
| Jermaine Waller | 26-yd. interception return | Notre Dame |
| Dorian Strong | 95-yd. blocked extra point return | Syracuse |
| TyJuan Garbutt | 16-yd. fumble return | Duke |
| 2022 (3) | Nyke Johnson | recovered blocked punt in end zone | Pitt |
| Tucker Holloway | 90-yd. punt return | Georgia Tech |
| Keli Lawson | 7-yd. interception return | Georgia Tech |
| 2023 (2) | Bhayshul Tuten | 99-yd. kickoff return | Florida State |
| Bhayshul Tuten | 94-yd. kickoff return | Virginia |
| 2024 (2) | Jaylin Lane | 58-yd. punt return | Marshall |
| Quentin Reddish | 77-yd. blocked field goal return | Clemson |
| 2025 (0) | none |