Virginia Tech
Hokies
1
Final
3
Boston College
Eagles
1234T
Virginia Tech (11-18, 6-12 ACC) 252019231
Boston College (17-14, 10-8 ACC) 222525253
  • November 28, 2014
    Power Gym, Chestnut Hill, Mass.
  • Start Time: 12:00 PM
  • End of Game: 2:06 PM
  • Total elapsed time: 2:06
    • Attendance: 215
    • 1st Referee: Brian Nobrega
    • 2nd Referee: Carole Burke
    ATTACK SERVE BLOCK
    #Virginia TechSKETAPct.ASTSASEREDIGBSBABEBHPTS
    5Kam McLain415426.42300002002015.0
    9Katty Workman413941.098210110001014.0
    10Sol Calvete45426.03833001202209.0
    12Kellie Barnum4409.44432020600024.0
    13Anna Skold46318.1670000104108.0
    14Julia Topor481132-.09411004020010.0
    1Mallori Moffat3001.0006000000000.0
    3Courtney Castle4000.00042001500002.0
    4Franny Hock3000.0000000000010.0
    7Lauren Fields4000.0001000200000.0
    11Sarah Mendes1000.0000000000000.0
    TMTEAM1000.0000002000000.0
    Total45131153.1314972352086362.0
    Team Attack By Set
    SetKETAPct.
    1121134.029
    212533.212
    3131037.081
    414549.184

    TOTAL TEAM BLOCKS: 4.0
    ATTACK SERVE BLOCK
    #Boston CollegeSKETAPct.ASTSASEREDIGBSBABEBHPTS
    1Lindsey Owens416541.268121113151021.5
    4Jordan Fish4002.00036110200011.0
    10Amanda McKinzie49431.16100151200009.0
    17Ashley Battle46112.4170000303207.5
    20Kathryn Caine45210.3000000204007.0
    32LaTasha Samson-Akpan412220.50000202162016.0
    2Kenedy McGrath4000.0001000400000.0
    5Kennedy Bryan48113.5380000000008.0
    13Katie Krueger1000.0000000200000.0
    15Kyra Coundourides4203.66717030100012.0
    21Megan Beckwith4000.00020111700000.0
    Total45815132.32657397582185272.0
    Team Attack By Set
    SetKETAPct.
    19733.061
    217435.371
    313020.650
    419444.341

    TOTAL TEAM BLOCKS: 11.0
    1234Total
    Tie Scores11111528
    Lead Changes13329
    Play-By-Play
    Game 1VT-BC
    VT starters: Kathryn Caine; Ashley Battle; Lindsey Owens; LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Jordan Fish; Amanda McKinzie; libero Megan Beckwith.
    BC starters: Sol Calvete; Anna Skold; Julia Topor; Katty Workman; Kam McLain; Kellie Barnum; libero Courtney Castle.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Sol Calvete (block by Kathryn Caine; LaTasha Samson-Akpan).1-0
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Anna Skold.2-0
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Service ace (TEAM).3-0
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Service error.3-1
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Kathryn Caine (from Jordan Fish).4-1
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Kellie Barnum (from Sol Calvete).4-2
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).5-2
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Katty Workman (block by Kathryn Caine; Ashley Battle).6-2
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).6-3
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Attack error by Julia Topor.7-3
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum).7-4
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Attack error by Julia Topor.8-4
    Point VT - [Lindsey Owens] Service ace (TEAM).9-4
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).9-5
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point BC - [Lauren Fields] Bad set by Kyra Coundourides.9-6
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).10-6
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Kyra Coundourides), block error by Anna Skold.11-6
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Attack error by Kennedy Bryan.11-7
    Point BC - [Kellie Barnum] Attack error by Lindsey Owens.11-8
    Point BC - [Kellie Barnum] Attack error by LaTasha Samson-Akpan.11-9
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides), block error by Sol Calvete.12-9
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Julia Topor.13-9
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).14-9
    BC subs: Mallori Moffat.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Sol Calvete (block by LaTasha Samson-Akpan).15-9
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Sol Calvete (from Katty Workman).15-10
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Attack error by Katty Workman.16-10
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).17-10
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Lindsey Owens (block by Julia Topor; Anna Skold).17-11
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Kam McLain (from Mallori Moffat).17-12
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Kam McLain (from Mallori Moffat).17-13
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Service ace (Amanda McKinzie).17-14
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Attack error by Kathryn Caine.17-15
    VT subs: Jordan Fish.
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Bad set by Jordan Fish.17-16
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Attack error by Kam McLain.18-16
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Ashley Battle.19-16
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Julia Topor.20-16
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by Lindsey Owens).21-16
    BC subs: Kellie Barnum.
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Kellie Barnum (from Katty Workman).21-17
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Attack error by Lindsey Owens.21-18
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Attack error by Ashley Battle.21-19
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum).21-20
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Service ace (Amanda McKinzie).21-21
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).21-22
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).21-23
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).22-23
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum).22-24
    Point BC - [Katty Workman] Ball handling error by Kyra Coundourides.22-25
    Game 2VT-BC
    BC starters: Katty Workman; Julia Topor; Anna Skold; Kam McLain; Sol Calvete; Kellie Barnum; libero Courtney Castle.
    VT starters: Kathryn Caine; LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Ashley Battle; Lindsey Owens; Jordan Fish; Amanda McKinzie; libero Megan Beckwith.
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Julia Topor (from Courtney Castle).0-1
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Kathryn Caine (from Jordan Fish).1-1
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Kellie Barnum (from Sol Calvete).1-2
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).1-3
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Attack error by Kathryn Caine.1-4
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Service ace (Amanda McKinzie).1-5
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).2-5
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Katty Workman.3-5
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum).3-6
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Ball handling error by Kellie Barnum.4-6
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Service error.4-7
    VT subs: Kennedy Bryan.
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).5-7
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point VT - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides), block error by Sol Calvete.6-7
    Point VT - [Lindsey Owens] Service ace (Katty Workman).7-7
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).7-8
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point BC - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Katty Workman (from Lauren Fields).7-9
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).8-9
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Kyra Coundourides).9-9
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Attack error by Katty Workman.10-9
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Service error.10-10
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).11-10
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Amanda McKinzie (block by Anna Skold; Sol Calvete).11-11
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Attack error by Anna Skold.12-11
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Service error.12-12
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).13-12
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Kellie Barnum (from Sol Calvete).13-13
    Point BC - [Julia Topor] Attack error by Lindsey Owens.13-14
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).14-14
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum).14-15
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Kill by Kyra Coundourides (from Kenedy McGrath).15-15
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point VT - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Lindsey Owens).16-15
    Point VT - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Ashley Battle (from Kyra Coundourides).17-15
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).17-16
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point BC - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum).17-17
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Kyra Coundourides).18-17
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Sol Calvete (from Kellie Barnum).18-18
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Attack error by Julia Topor.19-18
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Jordan Fish).20-18
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Jordan Fish).21-18
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Kathryn Caine).22-18
    BC subs: Mallori Moffat.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Amanda McKinzie (block by Sol Calvete; Anna Skold).22-19
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).23-19
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).24-19
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Katty Workman (from Mallori Moffat), block error by LaTasha Samson-Akpan.24-20
    BC subs: Franny Hock.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Ball handling error by Franny Hock.25-20
    Game 3VT-BC
    VT starters: Ashley Battle; Kathryn Caine; LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Amanda McKinzie; Jordan Fish; Lindsey Owens; libero Megan Beckwith.
    BC starters: Kellie Barnum; Kam McLain; Sol Calvete; Julia Topor; Katty Workman; Anna Skold; libero Courtney Castle.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum).0-1
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Jordan Fish).1-1
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Lindsey Owens).2-1
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Lindsey Owens).3-1
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Katty Workman (from Courtney Castle).3-2
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Katty Workman.3-3
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).4-3
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Service error.4-4
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Ashley Battle (from Jordan Fish).5-4
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Service error.5-5
    Point BC - [Katty Workman] Bad set by Kyra Coundourides.5-6
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Kyra Coundourides).6-6
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).6-7
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Kyra Coundourides (from Megan Beckwith).7-7
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Anna Skold (from Kellie Barnum).7-8
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Kyra Coundourides).8-8
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Megan Beckwith).9-8
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by Kathryn Caine; LaTasha Samson-Akpan).10-8
    BC subs: Mallori Moffat.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Anna Skold (from Mallori Moffat).10-9
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Service ace (Amanda McKinzie).10-10
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).11-10
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point BC - [Kenedy McGrath] Kill by Katty Workman (from Mallori Moffat).11-11
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Kathryn Caine (from Jordan Fish).12-11
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Kam McLain.13-11
    BC subs: Kellie Barnum.
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).13-12
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).14-12
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum), block error by Ashley Battle.14-13
    Point BC - [Katty Workman] Service ace (Lindsey Owens).14-14
    BC subs: Franny Hock.
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Kyra Coundourides).15-14
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    BC subs: Julia Topor.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Katty Workman (from Courtney Castle).15-15
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Attack error by Katty Workman.16-15
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Attack error by Sol Calvete.17-15
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Attack error by Sol Calvete.18-15
    BC subs: Sarah Mendes.
    Point VT - [Megan Beckwith] Ball handling error by Kellie Barnum.19-15
    BC subs: Sol Calvete.
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Sol Calvete (from Kellie Barnum).19-16
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Service error.20-16
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Anna Skold (from Kellie Barnum).20-17
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Service ace (Amanda McKinzie).20-18
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).21-18
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Anna Skold (block by Lindsey Owens; LaTasha Samson-Akpan).22-18
    BC subs: Mallori Moffat.
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Katty Workman.23-18
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Katty Workman.24-18
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Julia Topor (from Mallori Moffat).24-19
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).25-19
    Game 4VT-BC
    VT starters: Lindsey Owens; Ashley Battle; LaTasha Samson-Akpan; Kathryn Caine; Amanda McKinzie; Jordan Fish; libero Megan Beckwith.
    BC starters: Kam McLain; Julia Topor; Anna Skold; Kellie Barnum; Katty Workman; Sol Calvete; libero Courtney Castle.
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Kathryn Caine (from Jordan Fish), block error by Katty Workman.1-0
    Point VT - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Katty Workman.2-0
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by Lindsey Owens.2-1
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish), block error by Kam McLain.3-1
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum), block error by Lindsey Owens.3-2
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).4-2
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Service error.4-3
    Point BC - [Katty Workman] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).4-4
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).5-4
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).5-5
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Ashley Battle (from Kyra Coundourides).6-5
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Anna Skold (from Kellie Barnum), block error by LaTasha Samson-Akpan.6-6
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Kill by Kennedy Bryan (from Kyra Coundourides).7-6
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point VT - [Jordan Fish] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).8-6
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Kill by Anna Skold.8-7
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Sol Calvete (from Julia Topor).8-8
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Service ace (Megan Beckwith).8-9
    Point BC - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Katty Workman (from Courtney Castle).8-10
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by LaTasha Samson-Akpan (from Jordan Fish).9-10
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Attack error by LaTasha Samson-Akpan.9-11
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    Point BC - [Courtney Castle] Ball handling error by Jordan Fish.9-12
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).10-12
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Attack error by Kam McLain (block by Ashley Battle; Lindsey Owens).11-12
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum), block error by Ashley Battle.11-13
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).12-13
    VT subs: Kyra Coundourides; Kennedy Bryan.
    Point BC - [Kyra Coundourides] Kill by Julia Topor (from Kellie Barnum).12-14
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Attack error by Julia Topor (block by Ashley Battle; Lindsey Owens).13-14
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Kill by Kam McLain (from Kellie Barnum).13-15
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Kyra Coundourides).14-15
    Point BC - [Megan Beckwith] Kill by Sol Calvete (from Kellie Barnum).14-16
    Point BC - [Kellie Barnum] Attack error by Amanda McKinzie (block by Julia Topor; Anna Skold).14-17
    Point VT - [Kellie Barnum] Service error.15-17
    VT subs: Jordan Fish; Kathryn Caine.
    Point BC - [Jordan Fish] Attack error by Amanda McKinzie.15-18
    Timeout Virginia Tech.
    Point VT - [Sol Calvete] Kill by Amanda McKinzie (from Jordan Fish).16-18
    Point BC - [Amanda McKinzie] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum).16-19
    VT subs: Kenedy McGrath.
    BC subs: Kam McLain.
    Point VT - [Courtney Castle] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).17-19
    Point VT - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Kill by Kathryn Caine (from Jordan Fish), block error by Kam McLain.18-19
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point BC - [LaTasha Samson-Akpan] Service error.18-20
    Point VT - [Julia Topor] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).19-20
    VT subs: Katie Krueger.
    Point VT - [Katie Krueger] Kill by Ashley Battle (from Jordan Fish).20-20
    Timeout Boston College.
    Point VT - [Katie Krueger] Kill by Ashley Battle (from Jordan Fish).21-20
    BC subs: Franny Hock.
    Point VT - [Katie Krueger] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).22-20
    Point VT - [Katie Krueger] Kill by Lindsey Owens (from Jordan Fish).23-20
    BC subs: Julia Topor.
    Point BC - [Katie Krueger] Kill by Katty Workman (from Kellie Barnum).23-21
    Point VT - [Katty Workman] Attack error by Kam McLain.24-21
    VT subs: Amanda McKinzie.
    Point BC - [Lindsey Owens] Service error.24-22
    BC subs: Lauren Fields.
    Point BC - [Lauren Fields] Kill by Anna Skold (from Kellie Barnum).24-23
    Point VT - [Lauren Fields] Attack error by Katty Workman.25-23